In commercial transactions, the failure to fulfill contractual obligations by one of the parties may entitle the aggrieved party to compensation for damages and losses. In the Brazilian legal framework, such compensation is divided into two main categories:
- Actual damages (emergent damages): The tangible financial loss suffered, reflecting what has been directly lost.
- Lost profits (cessation of profits): The missed financial gains that would have been obtained had the harmful event not occurred.
Understanding the Concept of Damages in the Brazilian Context
In Brazil, as in many other legal systems, actual damages include the reduction of a company’s economic assets, encompassing expenses incurred due to the actions of third parties. These represent direct and measurable financial harm that has already materialized.
Lost profits, on the other hand, represent the frustration of expected financial growth resulting from a breach of contract or other harmful events. However, Brazilian law requires that lost profits be based on concrete evidence rather than speculation. This means they must be objectively determined using data and financial records preceding the harmful event.
The Role of Expert Analysis in Quantifying Damages
The quantification of both actual damages and lost profits often requires technical expertise and financial assessment methodologies. Courts and arbitration proceedings may rely on forensic accounting, financial modeling, and economic analysis to establish the extent of damages and provide a well-grounded assessment of the losses incurred.
In this context, expert evaluations play a fundamental role in establishing causality, financial impact, and the legitimacy of claims related to economic losses. The methodological approach taken in these assessments must align with both legal principles and economic reasoning, ensuring that compensation claims are supported by verifiable data.
Understanding these legal and financial principles is essential for businesses and professionals operating in Brazil and other jurisdictions with similar legal structures. Given the global nature of commerce, recognizing how damages and lost profits are assessed in different legal systems is key to mitigating risks and ensuring contractual compliance.
Image: © iStock.com/shironosov